Scott J. Winslow & Associates
onlinesales@scottwinslow.com PH: (800) 225-6233    FX: (603) 641-5583


LOT #98

 Andrew Carnegie to Joseph Choate 

 “WE ARE MARCHING ALONG THE PATH OF PEACE… …MUST HAVE YOUR BENEDICTION…” 

ANDREW CARNEGIE (1835-1919). Industrialist; Philanthropist. Shortly after immigrating to the U.S. from Scotland, Carnegie became private secretary to Thomas A. Scott who was just beginning his career with the Pennsylvania Railroad. Carnegie worked for Scott during the latter’s position as chief of railroad transportation for the Union during the Civil War and, at the end of the conflict, left Scott to build a successful business in the sales of railroad securities, oil brokering and bridge building. In 1873 Carnegie moved into the emerging steel industry, and he and his partners were responsible for making the U.S. steel industry the world leader by the turn of the century. After selling his enterprises to J.P. Morgan’s U.S. Steel in 1901, he spent the remainder of his life traveling and supporting his various philanthropies.

Typed Letter Signed. New York, March 23, 1911. One page. 8” x 11”. On his personal “Andrew Carnegie” letterhead. To Lawyer Joseph H. Choate, (1832-1917) Choate was involved in some of the country’s most publicized legal cases during the latter decades of the nineteenth century. President McKinley named him U.S. ambassador to Great Britain in 1899. Carnegie sends an inspirational letter:

“My dear friend – I hav (sic) yours of March 21st. My secretary tells me that not sending the money was an oversight, which has been remedied. We are marching along the path of peace. It will trouble us to keep pace with the procession. Very Truly Yours, Andrew Carnegie.”

In his own pen, he writes below: “We have your booklet for a great part very soon. Must have your benediction at Bishop Greers coming Holy Peace ceremony / ac.” Fold marks, mostly Very Good. Carnegie’s autograph is dark and strong.   $800. – up

Click to download Bid Sheet  Mail, Fax or Phone in your bid.
You may also email your bid at
onlinesales@scottwinslow.com

Terms of Sale
  1. All items are unconditionally guaranteed to be authentic. If an item is found not to be authentic, the full sale price will be refunded.
  2. A 15% BUYERS PREMIUM WILL BE ADDED TO THE FINAL HAMMER PRICE.
  3. All accounts are payable in full upon receipt of invoice unless other arrangements have been made prior to the sale. Any special credit terms should be made as early as possible. Title does not pass until full payment has been received.
  4. No "Buy" or unlimited bids will be accepted.
  5. We reserve the right to reject any bid we feel is not made in good faith.
  6. In the case of tie bids on the book, the earliest received shall take precedence.
  7. This is not an approval sale. Lots may not be returned except for reasons of authenticity or a material error in the catalog description.
  8. Please bid in U.S. dollars and only in whole dollar amounts. Fractions of a dollar will be rounded down to the nearest dollar.
  9. Some lots may be subject to a reserve.
  10. Shipping charges will be added to all invoices.
  11. The placing of a bid shall constitute the bidders acceptance of these terms of sale.

 This sale is being held under the laws of the State of Virginia.

Please contact onlinesales@scottwinslow.com for further assistance


Scott Winslow and Associates
Copyright 2007 - All Rights Reserved
Scott J. Winslow Associates, Inc